4 March 2019

Tenacious Planners win the day on appeal


According to 2018 research by Heriot-Watt University, England has a backlog of 3.91 million homes, meaning 340,000 new homes need to be built each year until 2031. In order to even come close to these targets, sites previously considered ineligible for development have become more likely to be subject to planning requests.

SHW Planning were instructed to submit a Planning Appeal for eight houses in the village of Frogmore in Devon, near the market town of Kingsbridge. The planning application had been refused due to the planning committee being unconvinced of the need for the development.


The land is located at the edge of an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. It was in a low lying area and bounded on development on two sides. Through review of Local Authority and Parish Council documentation, SHW Planning found there was a specific need for local affordable housing which the site could deliver.


Furthermore, through additional research, SHW Planning found there were no sites outside of the AONB which could deliver this need. This argument - combined with the limited contribution the site makes to the landscape resonated with the Planning Inspector who allowed the Appeal.


Alex Perraton of BBH Chartered Architects said: “It was a pleasure to work with SHW. The company showed professionalism, expert knowledge and valuable experience throughout the appeal and we are incredibly grateful for all their efforts, resulting in a favourable outcome. We would highly recommend SHW to anyone in need of Planning and Appeal assistance.”


SHW Planner Julia Mitchell said: It is always a fine balance between preserving the countryside and delivering development. In this case, the need for local affordable housing could not be met elsewhere. We were delighted that the Inspector recognised this. As a result, young families who were facing re-location due to unaffordable house prices will be able to stay in the village in which they settled.”


Julia Mitchell

01273 876266

back to newspreviousnext

Subscribe for more

share this article

Related articles

17 March 2021


full story

31 December 2020

Planning round up for 2020 and update for the New Year.

full story

11 September 2020

SHW Guide to the new Use Class Order in England & Wales

full story

5 June 2020

Planning Inspectorate - Appeal Timescales

full story

23 April 2020

How Covid-19 could change residential layouts & home working

full story

24 March 2020

SHW Planning team secures planning permission for new Commercial Units in Littlehampton

full story

26 February 2020

Planning Permission granted for prominent site in Battersea

full story

2 July 2019

Planning permission granted for CentrePoint at Burgess Hill

full story

4 June 2019

Permitted Development Rights – retail to office conversion

full story

8 May 2019

SHW Planning wins 24 residential unit consent - Chatham

full story

1 May 2019

SHW Planning Opinions Matter: What to make of proposed Permitted Development extensions?

full story

24 April 2019

Tungsten Properties achieves planning consent for West Sussex warehouse building

full story

16 April 2019

Planning Inspectorate overturn Hove decision on appeal

full story

19 March 2019

Outer London boroughs to play bigger role in provision of housing

full story

4 February 2019

Opinions Matter: New London Plan Housing Targets – Inner vs Outer

full story

4 February 2019

Possible Article 4 blocking new HMOs - Croydon

full story

8 January 2019

Southern counties missing out on New Year government bonuses

full story