News

14 September 2021

VP OR NOT VP: THAT IS THE QUESTION (And now we have an answer!)

Commercial, Professional services


The Court of Appeal’s recent ruling in the Capitol Park Leeds v Global Radio Services case on what constitutes Vacant Possession (VP) when it comes to the validity of a break clause highlights the pitfalls ahead for any tenant looking to action a break clause within their lease.



In brief, the tenant in question tried to break their lease in accordance with their break clause which stipulated that vacant possession had to be given. The tenant vacated the property of people and chattels but, in stripping out the premises ahead of exiting, they removed some of the landlord’s fixtures and fittings as part of these works.

 

The High Court ruled that VP had not been given in terms of the property’s physical state and that the tenant had therefore not actioned their break clause as per the lease.

 

However, the Court of Appeal has recently reversed this decision saying that VP should only mean that the premises are returned to the landlord free of people, chattels and legal interest. VP should not relate to the property’s physical condition.

 

Whilst this may seem like good news for all parties in that VP has now been more clearly defined, this is still a potential minefield, particularly for tenants. It is still open to interpretation in terms of what other conditions might apply to action a successful lease break, so good legal advice is recommended.

 

The pandemic and current market conditions have opened some interesting break clause opportunities for both landlords and tenants, and SHW is busy exploring these for clients. If you have break clauses coming up and would like advice on how to make these work for you, SHW would be delighted to discuss your situation and help advise on the best property strategy.


back to newspreviousnext

Author

Paul Wade

Lease Advisory

Partner (Head of Crawley Professional)

see more
More from this author

Subscribe for more

share this article

Related articles

17 December 2020

BRIGHTON PREPARES FOR A BRIGHTER FUTURE POST-COVID

full story

4 November 2020

Worthing industrial market continues to bounce back

full story

4 August 2020

Rent review successfully concluded on one of Brighton & Hove’s best estates

full story

24 June 2020

SHUTTLEWORTH JOINS SHW’S GROWING LONDON OFFICE

full story

4 May 2020

Brighton office market performing well in uncertain times

full story

27 April 2020

Valuations during COVID-19 lockdown

full story

26 March 2020

Landlords & Tenants - SHW are here to help

full story

18 March 2020

The Charities Act - Granting of a lease and complying with the Act

full story

2 March 2020

Lease regears at Leatherhead House create successful outcome for all

full story

17 January 2020

Ignore Rent Review Drafting At Your Peril

full story

5 January 2020

Helping charities stay compliant during uncertain times

full story

14 October 2019

Leasehold reform update

full story

2 October 2019

Medical premises payment changes 'to reduce costs and workload'

full story

25 September 2019

INSIGHT: Are some lenders living on borrowed time?

full story